McArthur River

This blog is dedicated to the protection of the McArthur River, Northern Territory, Australia.

Archive for the 'Northern Territory' Category


Xstrata finally makes payment

Posted by mcarthurriver on July 20, 2007

Amazing what happens when a bit of pressure is applied. It seems the open-cut mine is being credited with improving profitiability before it has even been developed. I wonder if the 26 million had anything to do with Clare Martin’s support for this project? what is the going rate for some ‘quick fix’ legislation to help a  mate? no wonder the Traditional owners couldn’t get a fair hearing.

 From Rueters

Swiss-based mining company Xstrata  said on Monday it had made an initial royalty payment to Australia’s Northern Territory government from its McArthur River zinc and lead mine, where it is appealing a court ruling against a major revamp.

Xstrata has been proceeding with construction work to transform the underground lode into an open pit mine while awaiting the outcome of an appeal over a court ruling that said the Northern Territory government failed to follow the correct legal procedure when it approved the revamp.

Xstrata has warned that if it not allowed to dig an open pit at the site — costing A$110 million ($96 million) — it will be forced to close the mine, which opened in 1995.

The company said it had made a royalty payment of A$13.06 million to the Northern Territory government, representing half the total payment for calendar 2007.

“Payment of royalties is largely dependent on global commodity prices and the recovery of costs of both the mine’s establishment and the open pit development,” Xstrata said in a statement Monday.

Xstrata wants to dig an open pit at the mine to replace an ageing underground operation that is running out of rich ore, requiring the diversion of the McArthur River for 5.5 km (3.4 miles).

It won approval from the Territory’s Ministry of Mines last year, but the decision was overturned by a legal challenge by traditional Aboriginal land owners. Environmentalists fear that prolonged rainy seasons pose a risk that contaminated seepage from mining and milling will reach the 300-km long McArthur River.

A changeover would give the mine the capacity to produce about 430,000 tonnes of zinc and lead-bearing concentrate a year, up from 320,000 tonnes.

It would also carry the potential to produce a bulk-type concentrate, or ground ore, with lower lead content, which could be processed in conventional smelters, the company said.

McArthur River yielded 135,000 tonnes of zinc in concentrate last year, but output was expected to be less than half that this year, allowing for the pre-stripping work needed for the move to an open pit. ($1=A$1.15)

Rueters…

Posted in Legal challenge, McArthur River, NT Government, Northern Territory, Traditional Owners, Xstrata | 2 Comments »

McArthur River Mine decision a victory for traditional owners

Posted by mcarthurriver on July 19, 2007

Northern Land Council (NLC) Chief Executive, Norman Fry, today declared that the judgment of the Northern Territory Court of Appeal in relation to McArthur River Mine was a victory for traditional owners.

“The only reason the Full Bench upheld McArthur River Mine’s appeal was because of the unfair and undemocratic retrospective legislation introduced by Chris Natt, which prevented the Court from considering Justice Angel’s decision.” 

“The Court refused to hear McArthur River Mine’s legal arguments. 

“The Full Court recognised the unfairness of the legislation to traditional owners by preserving Justice Angel’s decision that the Northern Territory Government and the mine pay the traditional owners’ legal costs of the court case,” said Mr Fry.

Traditional owners will continue their fight for justice including in Federal Court proceedings which resume on 30 July 2007 in Darwin.

Posted in Legal challenge, McArthur River, NT Government, Northern Territory, Traditional Owners, Xstrata | 2 Comments »

Xstrata appeals against mine expansion ruling

Posted by mcarthurriver on July 18, 2007

 The owners of the McArthur River mine near Borroloola in the Northern Territory have begun an appeal against a Supreme Court ruling in April, which blocked their expansion plans.

In October 2006 Minister Chris Natt approved an application by Xstrata to convert operations from underground to open cut and divert the McArthur River.

The Supreme Court later upheld legal action by traditional owners ruling the approval process was flawed.

The Northern Territory Government then legislated against that decision allowing the mine’s expansion to go ahead.

Despite this Xstrata is today appealing against the original court decision, which it argues still sets a legal precedent which could affect future mine approvals.

 from the abc…

Posted in Legal challenge, McArthur River, NT Government, Northern Territory, Traditional Owners, Xstrata | No Comments »

All the rivers run red: McArthur River is sacred land.

Posted by mcarthurriver on June 29, 2007

All the rivers run red: the blood-soaked Gulf Country and its McArthur River is sacred land.

by Peter Jull

A river is a powerful presence to anyone who has grown up with it, its local culture and economy. It follows one around, lifelong. It runs through one’s being. The Aboriginal river land- and waterscapes of the southern and south-western Gulf of Carpentaria are powerfully evoked in the opening section of Alexis Wright’s new novel, Carpentaria. The book begins:

The ancestral serpent, a creature larger than storm clouds, came down from the stars, laden with its own creative enormity. It moved graciously … It came down those billions of years ago, to crawl on its heavy belly, all around the wet clay soils in the Gulf of Carpentaria.

There is no such lyricism or feeling in the minds of McArthur River Mining/Xstrata minions. Their December 2005 public relations ‘fact sheet’ on riverine environments begins:

As part of McArthur River Mining ’s Environmental Management Plan, regular tests are done of the riverine and marine environments. We respect that the river, ocean, and the plants and animals they harbour, are important for many reasons, including their significance to local Aboriginal people.

Including their significance for Aboriginal people? These fellows are also operating in a primeval world, at least politically, before a time of respect for indigenous culture and rights. They are certainly not fit people to be digging up the region, let alone the main river of the district, the McArthur a ‘realignment’, they call it. One must doubt the extent of their relations with the locals, a matter brushed off as more than sufficient by the CEO when the new mining plan was approved (ABC, 21 October 2006).

As McArthur region traditional owner Barbara McCarthy put it in a passionate speech as a member in the NT legislature:

The Yanyuwa, Garrwa, Mara and Kudanji peoples sit in the gallery here tonight. They sit here to support me in the struggles that I face, not only as the member for Arnhem, but also in my responsibilities as a traditional owner, recognised and accepted by my own people. The indigenous people of the Gulf have travelled here from Borroloola to protest the expansion of this mine on the steps of Parliament House this week…. I could not in all good conscience not do so for our people have lived in the region for thousands and thousands of years and struggled for the strong recognition of land rights in the Gulf, rights that were hard won after 30 years and only handed back four months ago; rights that were fought for by people who have long since passed and who no longer walk this earth, but live through the hearts of their descendants. … Their concerns expand far wider than the Gulf country–concerns about water and how water is life. The indigenous people who are here in this parliament are troubled by the water crises they see right across Australia. Australia is looking to the north to resolve a growing water crisis in our eastern and southern states, and yet my people are very worried at the potential risk to one of our greatest waterways here in the Northern Territory.

As she says, governments who have presided over the disaster of Australia’s water supplies are hardly to be trusted. But the Prime Minister bullied the NT premier, Clare Martin, into a deal full of holes and corporate issues, while the national environment minister fell into line:

Senator Campbell says Indigenous people’s concerns about the diversion of the river are a matter for the Northern Territory Government…. Senator Campbell says he looked strictly at issues of national environmental concern.’ (ABC, 20 October 2006).

That’s one for the books!

Jacqui Katona, who led the successful battle against the Jabiluka Mine west and north of the Gulf Country, and Murrandoo Yanner, brought to public note by his spokesmanship and leadership in relation to the Lawn Hill and Century issues in the Gulf Country in the 1990s–a subject for which Carpentaria is in part a roman a clef, launched the book in Brisbane. They were angry. Murrandoo laid into modern-day Jackie-Jackies, naming names, and into the Prime Minister’s hand-picked black advisory group. Murrandoo said that the Gulf Country was still the land of his and related peoples, and that they would not be managed by white governments and developers. One hopes he is right.

The federal government’s delusions about a brave new indigenous policy don’t even begin to recognise indigenous political rights or imperatives. What are we to make of federal pretensions, as in Australian Financial Review (’Brough leads indigenous rethink’, 6 October 2006), when we read:

Indigenous affairs is rapidly becoming the crucible for a new approach to social policy and service delivery by the federal government. It is all about … the way Australian society sees its responsibilities towards its citizens.

Yes, much better some clear and appropriate anger than this foolishness.

My own river, the Ottawa, was the centre of the Algonkin people’s world; indeed, its watershed was their political and cultural region. It became a crucial economic thoroughfare of empire, first French, then British, from the early 1600s, with the fur trade and later the timber trade. Not for nothing, the song beginning ‘Was you ever in Quebec?/Bonny laddie, Highland laddie,/ Loading timber on the deck …’ was a favourite on the bagpipes as the Black Watch and others marched against the Americans and other Bad People around the world in the glory days of Empire, and since.

If ever there was a blood-soaked landscape it is the Gulf Country and its McArthur River. Days before she approved the McArthur mine, Northern Territory premier Clare Martin awarded the NT history prize to Tony Roberts’ Frontier Justice. She presumably had not yet read it. Its ‘fresh perspective’–her words–are an unrelenting documentation of genocide–blood and mud–of the peoples, and their survivors, in the Gulf Country. If Gallipoli is a sacred landscape for Australians, this is even more so.

This article has been borrowed from Arena publications - a worthy addition to anyones reading list http://www.arena.org.au/index.html

Peter Jull is Adjunct Associate Professor, Australian Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies (ACPACS), University of Queensland. 
  
 
 

Posted in John Howard, Labor Party, McArthur River, NT Government, Northern Territory, Pellew Islands, Traditional Owners, Xstrata | No Comments »

The River (McArthur)

Posted by mcarthurriver on June 27, 2007

majestic
life
meaning
culture.

mining
dollars
friends in high places.

Howard and Martin
obedient,
supplicant
misleading.

Approval.
destruction
racism
environmental folly.

repeat…

Posted in John Howard, McArthur River, NT Government, Northern Territory, Uncategorized | 1 Comment »